Areas once redlined on KC’s East Side miss out on COVID relief
This story was co-published in partnership with the Center for Public Integrity
Darryl Answer knows a lot of entrepreneurs in the majority-Black East Side of Kansas City, people running companies or side gigs. But the local pastor couldnât think of even one whoâs received help from the federal governmentâs pandemic lifeline for small businesses.
Thatâs because most hadnât.
In Kansas City neighborhoods seared by decades of government-imposed racial discrimination, the Paycheck Protection Programâs forgivable loans arrived last year at lower rates than in the rest of the city. East Side areas âredlinedâ in the 1930s because Black people lived there â a federal decision that effectively blocked investment â received 17% fewer PPP loans than if theyâd gotten an amount proportionate to their share of the cityâs small employers. Affluent, largely white ZIP codes given preferential treatment by redlining received 23% more.
âSometimes we look at this as an isolated situation,â said Answer, who is active in community development in addition to his work with New Community Church. âBut I think all of these things have to be experienced in light of history.â
This pattern keeps repeating â here and across the country. In Kansas City, your level of wealth and even the length of your life are often defined by whether you live east or west of Troost Avenue, a longstanding racial dividing line. Itâs a similar story in many other once-redlined cities.
At the same time, most of the government incentives intended to combat blight and joblessness in Kansas City flow downtown rather than to the East Side. Variations on that theme keep happening around the nation, too, an eerie â and legal â echo of what the 1930s federal Home Ownersâ Loan Corp. wrought with its red pen.
âYou canât call it anything but redlining: public sector reinforcing private-sector discrimination,â said Greg LeRoy, executive director of Washington, D.C.-based Good Jobs First, which tracks and researches economic subsidies. âThe net effect is reverse Robin Hood. Youâre favoring places that need help the least.â
In Kansas City, people determined to put a stop to this may be making some headway. In 2017, Black community leaders convinced voters to earmark a slice of sales-tax revenue for economic development and stability efforts in a portion of the East Side. Some of that money has flowed as COVID-19 relief to small businesses that largely missed out on the federal help.
And after a years-long pressure campaign by public school leaders, civic groups and others alarmed at the loss of tax revenue that would otherwise fund public services, the City Council imposed modest limits on tax incentives in February.
But what happened with the Paycheck Protection Program is just the latest reminder that equal opportunity remains miles off. Congress asked the Small Business Administration to prioritize small firms in âunderservedâ markets for PPP loans, which should have quickly boosted places like Kansas Cityâs East Side. And yet assumptions in the program design â about business ownersâ access to banking or certain documents or even clear information about who qualifies â didnât account for the reality that many firms in such markets face, according to interviews with several dozen experts and entrepreneurs.
Sixty-three percent of eligible applicants for the relief grants that Kansas City approved for East Side business did not get a PPP loan. A handful were turned down for PPP help, according to a survey by LISC Greater Kansas City, a field office of the Local Initiatives Support Corp., which administered the cityâs grants. Ten percent applied and got no response. Many didnât apply at all, in most cases because they hadnât heard about it.
Itâs a finding that LISC said befuddled some regional business leaders. Never heard of the much-discussed PPP?
But thatâs west-of-Troost thinking. For people living and working east of Troost, the LISC survey results show what officials should have known from the start: A program that isnât designed to counteract the effect of decades-long discrimination will probably replicate it.
âYou can write it in the law that youâre supposed to [beneficially] target Black and brown businesses, but then it gets out into the system,â said Melissa Patterson Hazley, vice chair of the board overseeing the economic development sales tax. âAnd the system isnât designed to do that.â
Separated by a few miles and a vast gulf
Darrian Davis co-founded a fledgling industrial hemp business and an urban farm cooperative. He also owns a construction contracting business, holds rental properties in a limited liability corporation and runs a side effort buying items from auctions to resell.
He received a PPP loan for none of them.
âI remember thinking that I wasnât going to be eligible,â he said. He kept hearing references to payroll, and he doesnât have employees, so he didnât apply.
Itâs possible he could have gotten PPP money. One-person operations can qualify, and the SBA tweaked the program in January and again in February and March to try to make it more equitable. Even so, Davis might have fallen through the eligibility cracks â or ended up like a small dessert maker near him who jumped through the hoops last year and received just $416.
The East Side ZIP code where Davis lives, 64128, was one of the few places in Kansas City where Black people were permitted to live during the redlining era. Even today, thereâs just one bank branch. Nearly a third of residents live below the poverty line. Home values are low, making it hard to build generational wealth.
When the SBA handed out PPP loans last year, only 59 made it to 64128. Compared with its share of small employers, thatâs one of the lowest levels in the city.
Public Integrity, which itself received PPP loans, sued the SBA last year to release the information about recipients that made this analysis possible. The newsroom melded that dataset with Census Bureau figures and redlining-map information from a team led by the University of Richmond. Itâs not a perfect measure because the federal government doesnât track the universe of potentially PPP-eligible businesses at a local level, but comparing loans to the share of small employers helps show which areas are getting more or less than expected.
For some very small businesses in 64128, both a lack of assistance and a process that seemed to be continually changing acted as barriers. As she attempted to keep renovations going on a transitional house for women leaving prison, Monecia Smith contacted the SBA for help. She said she didnât get anywhere. Then she reached out to Bank of America, but at that point last year the PPP funding was gone.
âI donât know anyone that applied for it,â said Answer, the pastor, who lives in that ZIP code. Some âhave multiple hustles, whether it be lawn care, catering, different things to survive. No oneâs making a ton of money.â
About two-and-a-half miles southwest, across the Troost Avenue divide, sits the 64113 ZIP code. Stretching from the state line to Oak Street, the zip code includes much of Brookside, reaching Gregory Boulevard to the south and W. 55th Street to the north.
Here, prohibitions on Black residents were written into deeds in a pre-redlining practice that developer J.C. Nichols helped spread around the country. The Home Ownersâ Loan Corp. graded these neighborhoods highly desirable in the 1930s, a stand-out green on a map pockmarked with red.
Today, 90 percent of residents in 64113 are white. The typical household makes $138,000, five times the figure in Davisâs community. And 64113âs access to PPP loans, 262 in all, was among the highest in Kansas City compared with its share of small employers â 92 loans more than would have been expected.
Those loans helped many of the businesses that define the Brookside area, including small shops, a barber, pet store and clothing boutique along and near 63rd Street. Nearby law offices, Realtors and restaurants also benefited.
Davis was not surprised to hear it. Just as the consequences of redlining still linger in his neighborhood, he said, marking some communities green has also compounded over time.
âAny disparity you can think of,â he said, âyouâll see the same pattern.â
In fact, only one Kansas City ZIP code that was predominantly redlined with Black residents in the 1930s did not have worse-than-average access to the PPP last year. A key secret to its success: Itâs almost entirely west of Troost Avenue, benefiting from years of investments in and around downtown.
The stark differences between neighborhoods in Kansas City can be found throughout America. Thatâs why Bruce Katz, director of the Nowak Metro Finance Lab at Drexel University, said the federal government must stop assuming that programs like the PPP are enough. Whatâs often missing in communities is a robust small-business support system to make sure people without banking connections or much money get the help, too.
âUnless youâre thinking about delivery of this locally, it falls flat,â Katz said. âWeâre trying to get it embedded in every part of Biden policy that we can.â
Michael L. Barrera, director of the SBAâs Kansas City district office, said that since he stepped into the job in February, heâs been on an outreach tear. A former president of both the Hispanic Chamber of Commerce of Greater Kansas City and U.S. Hispanic Chamber of Commerce, heâs been repeatedly talking to local business groups â including the Asian, Black and Hispanic chambers â about the PPP and other pandemic assistance programs.
âWe canât contact every business in our district, so we have to rely on our partners to do that,â he said. âAnd having relationships with these partners is going to be critical going forward.â
PPP data for January through March shows the once-redlined areas of Kansas Cityâs East Side still falling short, though the gap has narrowed. City Councilwoman Melissa Robinson, whose district includes 64128, traces those better results to all-hands-on-deck efforts by people on the East Side. She said she pressed to get funding for the local Prospect Business Association so it could help more firms with PPP applications.
And the Heartland Black Chamber of Commerce, headquartered in Kansas City and covering four Midwestern states, pieced together government funding and donations to launch its own program in February. By the third day, about 100 businesses had applied for the help.
âThe need is so great,â said Kim Randolph, chief executive of the organization.
Thereâs still time, though not a lot: The programâs application deadline is May 31. And the money might run out before then.
Kansas City Mayor Quinton Lucas, who grew up on the East Side, said the local experience with the PPP illustrates a broader national problem: The federal government keeps relying on local advocates to fix inequities that should have been anticipated from the start. âRarely are there ever exceptions, particularly when you see the initial rollout of programs,â he said. âIt is, as a Black man, incredibly frustrating.â
Not many of Randolphâs members obtained a PPP loan last year, when quick help was most needed. It was clear last spring that the pandemic was hitting U.S. communities of color particularly hard and fast â the number of Black small business owners dropped 41 percent nationally between February and April 2020, compared with 17 percent for white entrepreneurs. Randolph thinks the country should be ashamed of how the PPP rolled out.
âWhen the dust settles, weâre going to have a desert,â she said. âIf we donât do something about it now, weâre going to be in a worse situation than we ever thought we could be.â
One-eighth of a cent
For every dollar on which Kansas City collects sales tax, half a cent goes to parks. A quarter-cent flows to public-safety services. In two of the cityâs counties, an eighth of a cent goes to the zoo.
Leaders of the local Urban Summit wondered: What if an eighth of a cent also went to economic development east of Troost?
Among the people posing that question was Karen E. Curls, president of a real estate services company. Her father, one of the cityâs first African American real estate brokers, founded the firm in 1952 â four years after the U.S. Supreme Court declared racist restrictions in deeds legally unenforceable and 16 years before Congress passed the federal Fair Housing Act.
Those bans on real estate discrimination did not redress the damage already done. Areas like 64128 are caught in a vicious cycle, unable to get much investment because they were blocked from it for so long.
In theory, the cityâs tax incentives for economic development could disrupt that cycle. But a 2018 report for Kansas City pointed out what East Side residents knew years earlier: Most incentives go to projects in already âhigh-valueâ parts of the city, particularly downtown.
If Kansas City voters agreed to charge themselves an eighth-of-a-cent sales tax for East Side efforts, that money couldnât get diverted. It would be a step, Urban Summit leaders thought, toward banishing redliningâs ghosts.
âLetâs say that: a step,â Curls said. âBut this staircase is very long.â
Supporters of the tax gathered signatures to put the measure on the ballot, then went door to door in 2017, urging people on both sides of the Troost divide to vote yes.
Thatâs generated more than $32 million over three-and-a-half years for an area that stretches from a street just east of Troost to the western quarter of 64128. Money is flowing to projects ranging from a shopping center renovation to a new childcare center, filling gaps in financing.
âThe one-eighth-cent sales tax is really a godsend for us,â said Marquita Taylor, president of the Santa Fe Area Council, whose neighborhood is receiving $610,000 to help residents fix roofs and make other home repairs. What Santa Fe pieced together for the project isnât enough, Taylor said, but still, âthe impact is going to be so great.â
The sales tax is an idea people in other cities could try. But itâs no cure-all, as Curls warned. It runs out in 2027 unless voters reauthorize it for another decade. Work was painfully slow to get started. And the amount of money pales compared with development needs, frustrating residents as proposed projects lose out.
The city tax incentives that largely go elsewhere, meanwhile, are far larger.
Those incentives drained nearly $100 million in revenue from the city in 2019 alone, according to a calculation by Good Jobs First. Thatâs mostly through programs that let developers put money they would have paid in taxes toward project costs instead.
The Kansas City Public Schools district serves a portion of the city that includes both the heavily subsidized downtown and the 64128 ZIP code. Its officials calculated that the district lost $1,069 per student to tax abatements in the 2018-19 school year â far more than other, mostly whiter districts in the city.
âEnough is enough,â Superintendent Mark T. Bedell wrote in a 2020 letter after a firm that had its property tax wiped out for two decades asked for 13 years more. That âspeaks loudly to the systemically racist real estate practices we have allowed to exist here.â
Amid growing outrage, the City Council denied the firmâs request and recently reduced the level of incentives developers can get. The council also tweaked rules to better target tax breaks to the distressed neighborhoods that keep missing out. But exceptions in the new law could undermine that goal.
Robinson, the councilwoman, wants more reform because she sees no practical difference between redlining and modern-day decisions about where to funnel investment. âItâs just much more covert,â she said.
Ajia Morris, an East Side resident who rehabs houses locally, would like efforts that invest âdirectly in the people who live there.â Support for small businesses, for instance, or a mortgage pool to help renters buy. Her company, The Greenline Initiative, named in reaction to redlining, finds that East Side rents are just as high as â or higher than â a mortgage would be.
Morris, a lawyer and former school board member, said what gets classified as âinvestmentâ in the area often extracts money from the people there rather than going to them.
One program launched by the cityâs health department and a local community development corporation last year does get funds into the hands of startups on the East Side, though the grants are small â $2,000 maximum. Kansas City and the Community Capital Fund see entrepreneurship as a way to increase well-being in an area where, in the case of 64128, people die nearly 18 years younger on average than in the greenlined 64113. (The reason for that disparity, the health department says in a blunt assessment: racism, including the âdevastating & lasting impactâ of redlining and later practices.)
Megan Crook, who led the Community Capital Fund when the program launched, said residents âknow whatâs going on in their neighborhood, they want to address it, they have the energy and ideas to address it. Thereâs just a lack of resources, a lack of a platform.â
Davis, whose industrial hemp startup received one of those micro grants, said lack of resources is exactly what makes the PPP harder to get in his community. Businesses without a lawyer or an accountant are at a disadvantage â and itâs no accident that his community has so many like that.
He sees redlining at the root.
âAccess to capital is the main thing,â he said. âAccess to capital. Thatâs what we need.â
The Starâs Kevin Hardy contributed to this report.
Jamie Smith Hopkins is a senior reporter and editor at the Center for Public Integrity, a nonprofit investigative news organization in Washington, D.C. She can be reached at email@example.com. Public Integrity data journalist Pratheek Rebala contributed to this article.
BEHIND OUR REPORTING
How the data was analyzed
The Center for Public Integrity, a nonprofit newsroom based in Washington, D.C., relied on multiple datasets for the analysis in this story.
The key comparison uses Paycheck Protection Program data from the Small Business Administration by ZIP code alongside small employer figures from the Census Bureauâs ZIP Codes Business Patterns. We calculated each areaâs share of Kansas City small employers, firms with fewer than 500 employees. Then we determined how many more â or fewer â PPP loans each ZIP code received than it would have gotten had it received the same share of loans as its share of small employers.
Thereâs no way to determine what percentage of eligible businesses received a loan. Thatâs because entrepreneurs without employees can apply for help from the PPP, too, and the Census Bureau doesnât track their numbers by ZIP code. But our comparison shows which areas got a lot of access to the program, or just a little, compared with their employer base.
Public Integrity also relied on census demographic figures and âredliningâ maps from the University of Richmond, which led a team that digitized documents from the federal Home Ownersâ Loan Corp. These detail the U.S. governmentâs Depression-era redlining grades around the country.
This practice hardened patterns of real estate discrimination, with long-lasting effects. As the University of Richmond notes on its âMapping Inequalityâ site, âHOLC assumed and insisted that the residency of African Americans and immigrants, as well as working-class whites, compromised the values of homes and the security of mortgages.â
As a result, the university said, the federal government âdirected both public and private capital to native-born white families and away from African American and immigrant families.â
Areas colored green on HOLC maps, graded âA,â were deemed a good risk for bank investment. Areas given the lowest grade, âD,â were colored red and declared âhazardousâ for investment. In Kansas City, not all redlined areas had Black residents. But all areas with more than a handful of Black residents were redlined. Black residents still make up many of the residents in these investment-starved neighborhoods today.
Public Integrity determined which ZIP code each graded area fell into, then identified each ZIP with a recorded number of Black residents at the point of redlining (that is, more than âfewâ) and more than half of the land area graded âD.â Four of the five are on the cityâs East Side, the geographic focus of our story, and together these four received substantially less access to the PPP than if the loans had been equally distributed around the city. ZIP codes where more than half the land area was graded âAâ or âBâ â both west of Troost â received markedly more.
So: What about that single ZIP code, 64108, that sits against the cityâs western boundary but was also largely graded D and had a recorded number of Black residents at the time? All but a small piece is west of Troost Avenue, which became the cityâs de facto racial dividing line, and itâs had a different trajectory than the East Side â with far easier access to lending, including the PPP.
Victoria Orozco at Drexel Universityâs Nowak Metro Finance Lab, Robert Nelson at the University of Richmond, Brent Never at the University of Missouri-Kansas City and the National Community Reinvestment Coalitionâs Bruce Mitchell, Jason Richardson and Jad Edlebi offered feedback and advice at various stages of the analysis.